MethodMath
Sarah Mitchell
Apr 29, 2026

Can someone explain the hilbert hotel paradox simply why is infinity not a number

I heard about Hilberts hotel. The one with infinitely many rooms thats always full but can always take more guests.

If the hotel is full and 1 more person shows up, each guest moves to room n+1 and room 1 is free.

But if the hotel is INFINITE and FULL, how can there be room? This sounds like a contradiction.

And if an infinite number of buses each carrying infinite passengers shows up, the hotel still has room! How??

My teacher said this proves infinity is "not a number" but I dont understand what that means. It seems like a number to me, just a really big one.

1 answers3.2k views
2 comments
Sarah Mitchell
Sarah MitchellApr 30, 2026

this broke my brain thank you

Alex Kim
Alex KimApr 30, 2026

try thinking about it this way: infinity is a property of sets, not a number. "infinite" describes the set, not a quantity.

Login to comment

1 Answer

Prof. Chen Wei
Prof. Chen WeiApr 29, 2026 Accepted
Great question! The Hilberts Hotel paradox shows exactly why infinity is NOT a number. **If infinity were a number, then $\infty + 1 > \infty$.** But with infinite sets, adding one element doesnt change the "size" — theres a bijection between the set and itself plus one element. For Hilberts Hotel: Map guest $n$ to room $n+1$. This is a bijection between $\{1,2,3,\ldots\}$ and $\{2,3,4,\ldots\}$, proving they have the same cardinality ($\aleph_0$). **For the infinite buses:** Use the Cantor pairing function. Map bus $b$, seat $s$ to room number: $$f(b,s) = \frac{(b+s-1)(b+s-2)}{2} + s$$ This gives a 1-to-1 mapping between $\mathbb{N} \times \mathbb{N}$ and $\mathbb{N}$, proving countability. The lesson: Infinite sets have proper subsets of the same size, which never happens for finite sets. This is the defining property of infinite sets.

Login to comment

Login or Register to post an answer